Ye Olde Thrift Shoppe - Oradell, New Jersey

Natalia Ortiz

Rude owner! Doesn’t even say hello. Has no idea what customer service or client experience is. I had not planned on stopping in, but was out for a walk and storefront caught my eye. You never know what treasures lurk in a thrift shop. There are certainly none here. The store is old, musty, dusty and smelly. Highest item of quality is Coach. Yet somehow, I found a few jewelry items to gift to a collector. No thank you or anything, just rude and admonishing. There are multiple reviews here that state similar interactions. You are better off shopping on the Real Real or with higher quality thrift shops. There are plenty and with better items.

Juanita Ray

I had an unpleasant visit to this thrift store. I went to put some items on consignment. The owner was not nice. She told me I had to have an appointment. I told her I’m sorry, I didn’t see that on the website. She said I do have time available to look at my stuff then. I looked around for about 15 minutes. She claims that it was nothing good for consignment. My stuff was up to date and in good condition. I don’t think she even looked in my bag. I don’t know if she is prejudice or what, but I would not shop there or recommend this place to anyone.

Sara Paolini-Vasquez

If I could give zero stars I would! The woman was rude and told me my clothes were “old”, which I took to mean that they were out of style, but she hardly even looked through the dozen hanging clothes I had. Meanwhile I’m looking around the store and everything in the store looked like it was straight out of the 70s! Stay away.

Update in response to the “owner’s” reply. She didn’t look through any of my items, just looked at the first dress on the hanger. All she said was “they’re old” and walked away. The items I brought in were timeless.

Denise Gonzalez

I've been a customer and consignor for many years. The owner knows her customers and due to the size of the shop she must be selective. Always find a treasure when I go ?46 years in business says it all!

Andrew Cronin

This is honestly the only thrift shop I go to. Barb the owner is really cool and only accepts clothes of the highest quality. I decided to run in this morning before work and found a beautiful designer shirt still new with the tag on it for $10 dollars! If you want to save money but still have great quality or are in between sizes like I am this is definitely the place to go. Thanks again.

Doreen Squitieri

Went here for the first time to bring things in for consignment NO WHERE on the website does it state by appointment or have the clothes on hangers. The owner was rude and nasty and condescending made me very uncomfortable. I WILL NEVER EVER RETUTN

Jill Clark

I love, love, love this place. The owner and the customers are great. You not only find the greatest clothes and accessories you also make some friends!!!!

M Gomez

First time going with my daughter found exactly what she was looking for!! Amazing jewelry and clothing!! Can’t wait to go back!!